The poem is dated June 29th, 1911, and was first published in the Morning Post on May 29th, 1911. The poem is listed in ORG as verse No. 967 (p. 5433). It is collected in:
- The Years Between (1919)
- Inclusive Verse (1919)
- Definitive Verse (1940)
- Sussex Edition Volume 33, p. 354
- Burwash Edition, Volume 26
- The Works of Rudyard Kipling (Wordsworth Poetry Library) 1994
The poem contrasts the high-minded sentiments expressed by men of all parties at the time of the Coronation of George V on June 23rd, 1911, and the resumption of party politics soon after, with politicians voting along party lines irrespective of the dictates of their consciences.
The Coronation, in Westminster Abbey, was an occasion of great pomp and ceremony, attended by the great and good of the land, including the Lords and the Commons, and celebrated all over the Empire. Many noble sentiments were uttered in a solemn atmosphere of national unity.
This was, however, a time of political turmoil in Britain, with the Liberal Government at odds with the Conservative-dominated House of Lords over the powers of the Lords over legislation, and with the Ulster Unionists over Irish Home Rule, against a backdrop of strikes and industrial unrest.
The Liberals, under Herbert Asquith and David Lloyd George, and detested by Kipling, had been in power since the end of 1905. They had embarked on a major programme of reform which Kipling violently disapproved of. This included a confrontation with the House of Lords, which was dominated by the Conservatives, which led to the powers of the Lords being severely curtailed. Such were the deep-seated differences between Government and Opposition that it would have been inconceivable for politicians to set aside party loyalties in mid-1911.
Kipling believed that the Liberal leaders were failing to arm Britain against overseas threats, selling out the Empire, including the Protestants of Ulster, and that they were in politics in order to line their own pockets. He had never had a high opinion of politicians as a class; indeed his picture of the lying boastful chattering monkey people, the bandar-log in The Jungle Book of 1894, was probably close to his view of the House of Commons seventeen years later.
The Declaration of London
This was an international code drawn up by a committee of experts following the Hague Conference of 1907, which set out various principles for the regulation of shipping in times of conflict. The rather weak provisions relating to the right of a nation in time of war to confiscate cargo on the high seas which might have been used by an enemy were objected to by various British interests. The House of Lords refused to ratify the Naval Prize Bill which was based on the Declaration. Kipling’s concern at that time was the vulnerability of Britain, as an island nation, to having its food supplies cut off. (See also his poem Big Steamers, published the same year)
However, after the war, as Kipling indicated in a letter of 18 March 1919 to Frank Doubleday, and as historians since have agreed, the fact that the Declaration never came into force was fortunate, since this had made it much easier for Britain to cut off the Central Powers from overseas supplies.
See The Letters of Rudyard Kipling, Ed. Pinney, vol.4 p. 541 and note 6 on p. 545. . Professor Pinney points out that Kipling had been incorrect to state that the House of Lords had refused to ‘abrogate’ the Declaration, since they had actually refused to support it. He describes Kipling’s description of the Declaration as ‘obscure’.
See also Kipling’s story Sea Constables.
©John Radcliffe 2011 All rights reserved