A Book of Words

Selections from speeches and addresses
delivered between 1906 and 1927
This is one of the six later speeches not included in that collection which were added for the Sussex Edition



XXXIII

"Healing by the Stars"


Annual dinner of the Royal Society of Medicine
May Fair Hotel, 15 November 1928



Notes edited
by Leonee Ormond

Introduction
Notes on XXXII
Notes on XXXIV


[April 25th 2011]

Publication

Published in The Times 16 November 1928, page 18. Published in The Lancet as ‘The Story of Nicholas Culpeper: Astrologer-Physician’, 24 November 1928, page 1061. Published as "Healing by the Stars" in pamphlet form, Doubleday, New York, 1928. Collected in the Sussex Edition vol. XXV, pp. 293-99, together with the earlier speeches collected in A Book of Words, and in the Burwash Edition vol. XXIV.

Background

Kipling and Winston Churchill were the guests of honour at the annual dinner. Kipling wrote to Peter Stanley on 26-28 November 1928:

I made a speech at the R.Society of Medicine (maybe you saw it in the Lancet) on the old “astrological” lines we discussed more than a year ago. It was rather fun but it has unchained on me every dam’ astrological crank in England (with pamphlets!) and the U.S. mail has yet to come.
[Letters, (Ed. Thomas Pinney) vol 5. p. 460].
Kipling spent much of his speech talking about Nicholas Culpeper, the seventeenth century physician. His argument was that Culpeper, as an astrologer, believed in the unity of the universe. Kipling declared that Culpeper would find much to confirm his belief in modern science and medicine. Kipling feared that recent scientific discoveries had made medicine more limited in approach.

In July 1928 he had visited an international conference on cancer hosted by the Royal Society of Medicine which was presided over by his friend Bland Sutton. In a letter to his daughter Elsie he wrote:

'... at the end an exhibition was given where the cells were all illuminated white against black, and it was like staring into the Heavens. Just the same as the nebula....'
[Letters, (Ed. Thomas Pinney) vol 5. p. 448].
See also his "A Doctor of Medicine" in Rewards and Fairies, his poem "Our Fathers of Old", Dr Gillian Sheehan's article on "Kipling and Medicine", and —in particular—his story "Unprofessional" (October 1930), collected in Limits and Renewals, which developed the ideas expressed in this speech.



Notes on the text

(the page and line numbers below refer to the
Uniform Edition of A Book of Words Macmillan, London 1928)


[Page 295 lines 6-7] Colonel MacArthur William MacArthur (later Sir William), Professor of Tropical Medicine at the Royal Army Medical College. He had served in India and was a pioneer in the treatment of cysticerus, a rare disease usually found in soldiers who had been in India.

[Page 295 line 10] Lord Dawson Bertrand, Viscount Dawson (1864-1945) The first physician in practice to be created a peer. President of the Royal College of Physicians from 1931 to 1938.

[Page 295 lines 10-11] Royal Society of Medicine founded in 1805 as the Medical and Chirurgical Society of London.

[Page 295 line 14] Nicholas Culpeper (1616-54) physician and astrologer. Culpeper enraged the medical establishment of his day by translating their Latin Pharmacopoeia into English. Culpeper is the central character in "A Doctor of Medicine" in Rewards and Fairies and Kipling also refers to him in "Wireless" in Traffics and Discoveries (p. 215 line 18).

[Page 295 line 15] Spitalfields market area in the East of the City of London.

[Page 295 line 24] decumbiture taking to one’s bed. The word is to be found on page ix in the Preface to the 1789 edition of the English Physician and Complete Herbal:

... the natural ground of medicine and disease ... depends much upon astral influx and elementary impression; and hence it is, that, by the nativity or decumbiture of the patient, we are enabled to discern both the cause and conclusion of the disease.
[Page 296 lines 10-13] this creation ... high as the stars Kipling is drawing together some of Culpeper's statements from The English Physician Enlarged and combining them into a single sentence. All references are to the edition of 1789. In speaking of 'contraries', Kipling omits Culpeper's reference to God:

'The hand eternal, in the beginning, when he formed the creation, made it a composition of contraries' ... (I, 59) 'if we consider that the whole creation is one entire and united body, composed by the power of an All-wise God, of a composition of discords'... (I, 63) 'Man is an admirable creature, the universe and epitome of the world'. (II, 3)
[Page 296 line 17] pneuma breath of life

[Page 296 line 18] St Paul preached at Athens see Acts 17, 15-21.

[Page 296 line 23] Aristotle (384-322 BC) the great Greek philosopher.

[Page 296 line 30] Royal Society the Royal Society is the leading scientific organisation in Britain. To be made a Fellow of the Royal Society (F.R.S.) is to be recognised as highly eminent in one's field.

[Page 297 line 17] Greenwich Observatory the Royal Observatory (on zero meridian) is in Greenwich Park in south-east London.

[Page 297 line 24] B.B.C. British Broadcasting Corporation.

[Page 299 lines 17-18] Perhaps a quote from Culpeper.



[L.O.]

©Leonee Ormond 2011 All rights reserved